sedimentaryreverie

replied to your post

“Also Watching Witchy Youtubers”

Communism has caused more pain and suffering than capitalism ever has

Alrighty, I’m assuming you’re thinking of the Soviet Union and other Leninist states, which were/are not communist in any sense of the word, but even assuming it was, let’s have a look at how Leninist states stack up? (note: As a libertarian communist my analysis is that Leninist states are essentially state capitalism and so their atrocities are also capitalist atrocities but JUST FOR FUN BECAUSE YOU THINK THAT’S WHAT COMMUNISM IS LET’S HAVE A LOOK AT HOW THEY STACK UP)

At the high point in the US the incarceration rate was higher than it was during the high point of the gulag system in Soviet Russia.

The NSA monitors our data in a way the Soviet surveillance state would be proud of

We use solitary confinement which is unquestionably torture 

We frame political dissidents for crimes and torture them (seriously)

We back states like Saudi Arabia and Sudan known for their consistent and unconscionable human rights violations.

We’ve supported literal genocide

We censored media because we thought it was “politically dangerous”

We backed the fucking Khmer Rouge (supposed communists, because we were scared of the other, frankly nicer communists)

and that’s mostly just the US.  Oh and don’t try and claim that the US wasn’t violent post-revolution, loyalists were persecuted plenty 

Hell let’s have some more:

The  1850–73 famine in China that killed over 60 million people as a result of imperialism and the opium wars.

Here are some gems from a list I found on a forum of atrocities capitalism must answer for if you’re going to hold it to the same standard you hold your idea of communism to:

What is the Belgian Kongo and the mess of states left after?

What is French Algeria?

What is British India and Pakistan?

What is the Native American Genocide in North America?

What is the Iraq War?

What is the Yemeni Civil War, and the US supporting Saudi bombing campaigns on civilian targets, during a famine?

What is De Beers?

What is the 1973 CIA funded coup of Allende in Chile?

What is the Contras in Nicaragua?

What is violence and regime change in the Honduras?

What is the genocide of Chinese people in Indonesia?

What is the Vietnam War?

What is the CIA funding of Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge?

What is the Syrian Crisis and the Pentagon funding one side, while the CIA funds another?

What is post French Rwanda and the genocide that followed?

What is the Irish Potato Famine?

What is the funding of Afghani Taliban during the USSR’s invasion on Afghanistan?

What is the 1954 Guatemalan Coup d’Etat?

What is Koch Industries bankrolling the Nazi oil industry?

What is Allied Powers supporting the Tsarists during the Russian Civil War?

What is the continued occupation and bombing campaigns against the Palestinian people?

What are the lies and corporate greed that led to the 2008 crash?

What is the Libyan conflict?

What is the entire oil industry?

What is the lobbying of government by companies like Haliburton, owned by Dick Cheney, to go on with perpetual warfare?

What is child labour in Asian countries and the Industrial Revolution?

What is Exxon Mobile covering up their data on climate change?

What is the private prison industry?

And I COULD LIST MORE.

So basically what did Leninist states do that wasn’t capitalist business as usual?
(…like it was capitalism where striking was illegal but you got free healthcare so it was sort of… eh y’ know swings and roundabouts)

Ideas On A Collectivized English Country Estate

Actually a collectivized English country estate sounds like it could be a very pleasant place to live, basically some people choose to do the farming and live in the cottages (that have been renovated to be super charming and nice) some people live in the big house and they do all the domestic labor and cooking for the people who do the farming, including like laundry, cleaning, clothes mending and maybe even clothes making and so on and like you can switch out if you don’t like the role you’re doing. Ladies maids could be like inhouse beauticians and governesses could mind the collectively cared for children in the nursery while the parents worked… seems sort of idyllic. You could also have your doctor and dentist and vet there, your tailor, your mechanic, a hub for public transport to places outside of the village and like you could put your library there, and like a woodworking workshop and like a place for big expensive tools you don’t need all the time (like lathes and table saws and belt sanders) because they have a ton of room, so basically it’s like a service hub at the center of a big circle and you could have your social functions (dances, weddings, town meetings etc) there, and it would also probably be your designated place to go in case of natural disaster, and you could also store things like a snowplow and backhoe and things for common use there, also maybe your local school depending on the size of things and the outbuildings and you’d go there for meals.

Also you could have a tailor there because getting things tailored is nice. It’d also be nice because you’d always have access to the stuff that you like need sometimes but not all the time (like floor waxers, and carpet steamers and weird special cake pans and other special pastry equipment, and stud finders and sewing machines, and like fancy audio equipment for recording whatever, and nice cameras and double boilers because they’d be shared in common and you could have enough that you were never like “awww someone took the last good camera” (also you’d probably get some of that stuff for people who needed it often) and you could have a giant store of board games and it’d be easy to find people to play with.  Everyone would get fresh fluffy towels delivered like in a hotel… like it wouldn’t be the thing for everyone but for people who like that sort of thing it’d be lovely, and you’d be able to keep horses and things for people who like different sorts of sports and probably have like fancy spa equipment and a collective gym… basically it’d be like ALL THE AMENITIES which’d be cool.

Imagine the giant awesome playground you could have for the kids, and like the super cool treehouse/s you could have for them to hang out in and like a giant shared dollhouse and things like that for the nursery playroom, and the like gigantic blowout birthday/Halloween/other holiday parties you could have because there’s this giant fancy house available, and a bunch of specialist cooks so you could have awesome food and people’d pitch in to decorate (also like onsite petting zoo basically lol) Fuck you’d probably have room in one of the out buildings to store a bouncy house if needed)

Can I Just Briefly Talk About How Creepy The Increased Restrictiveness In A Lot Of Sex Worker’s Sites TOS Is

Given the political climate, banning vampirism and castration fantasies from niteflirt may not seem like a big deal but it seems to me to be intimately linked with the gradual erosion of rights, and the increase in right wing censorship one would expect to see in Trump’s America.

Just wanted to point out that’s creepy, esp. in conjunction with the shutting down of backpage and just overall increased scrutiny and restriction in terms of free speech.